Skip to the page

Stablecoin Depeg: Why Some Coins Recover and Others Never Do

USDC fell to 86 cents in March 2023 and came back. Terra never did. What backs a coin, and who can redeem it, decides how a depeg ends.

A US five-cent coin standing on its edge on a dark wooden table beside a bright window, in black and white.

Photo: Joey Kyber on Pexels

#stablecoin-depeg

A stablecoin depeg recovers when something real stands behind the dollar the coin promises, and when holders can get to it. USDC slid to 86 cents at its trough in March 2023 and climbed back because its reserves were cash and assets that could be paid out. Terra, the largest algorithmic stablecoin before May 2022, had no such floor and did not come back.

So the useful question for anyone holding a balance in a stablecoin is not whether it can wobble. It can. The question is what sits behind it, who can redeem, and what happens to that backing under stress. If you want the short definition first, our depeg meaning explainer covers it. This note follows three designs through three documented breaks.

What decides whether a stablecoin depeg recovers?

Three things: what backs the coin, who can swap it for that backing, and whether the backing holds its value while everyone tries to leave at once. Each design answers those differently, which is why their depegs end so differently.

Backing designWhat is supposed to restore the pegDocumented breakHow it ended
Fiat reserves (USDC)Redemption at a dollar from cash and short assetsSilicon Valley Bank failure, March 2023Recovered after depositors were fully protected
Crypto collateral (DAI)Liquidating vaults before collateral falls below the debtBlack Thursday, March 2020System ended in deficit after zero-bid auctions
Algorithmic (Terra)Minting and burning a linked tokenCollapse, May 2022Death spiral, no recovery

What happens when a fiat-backed stablecoin loses its peg?

A fiat-backed coin loses its peg when holders doubt the reserves can be paid out in full. When Silicon Valley Bank failed, Circle was unable to withdraw $3.3 billion of USDC reserves, around 8% of the total at the time, and the price fell to 86 cents.

The detail most depeg recaps leave out is how thin the cushion was. Circle's total stockholders' equity was $0.34 billion as of December 31, 2023, a fraction of the balance stuck at the bank. What closed it was outside the issuer: the Treasury, the Federal Reserve and the FDIC fully protected all depositors in the affected banks, insured or uninsured.

Once the reserves were whole again, redemption did the rest. From Monday morning, Circle redeemed $3.8 billion of USDC and minted $0.8 billion, so far more coins were going back to the issuer than coming out. That is a fiat-backed coin working as designed: holders return coins, the issuer pays dollars, and the market price closes the gap because the dollar exit is real again.

Who can redeem a stablecoin for a dollar during a depeg?

Usually not you. Fiat-backed issuers tend to mint and burn only with institutional customers, as of the Federal Reserve's February 2024 note, so a retail holder's way out during a depeg is selling on the secondary market at whatever the market pays.

That matters more than any reserve report. The redemption promise holds the peg because large customers can buy the cheap coin on an exchange and redeem it at a dollar with the issuer. You benefit from that arbitrage, but you are not part of it. If you sell during the trough, you take the trough price. Our guide on buying stablecoin by minting or exchange walks through the same split from the entry side.

How does a crypto-collateralized stablecoin break?

A crypto-collateralized coin breaks when liquidations fail to recover enough collateral to cover the debt. DAI's Black Thursday in March 2020 is the clearest documented case: during the price crash only one keeper kept bidding in liquidation auctions, and it bid $0 for the ETH.

Vaults were liquidated with zero DAI coming back into the system, and Maker's governance forum recorded the result plainly: the system went from a +$500k surplus before the price drop to a -$4M surplus to fill. The design assumed many bidders competing for discounted collateral. When it mattered, there was effectively one, and it paid nothing.

The lesson for holders is that overcollateralization is only as good as the liquidation machinery. The collateral was there on paper. The auctions that were meant to turn it back into DAI did not price it.

Why do algorithmic stablecoins spiral instead of recovering?

An algorithmic stablecoin spirals because its backing is a token the system itself creates. When holders exit, supply of the backing crypto-asset rises as the stablecoins are removed from circulation, which pushes that token's price down just as the stablecoin needs it to be worth more.

The Federal Reserve note describes this collateral design as having led to the death spirals of several algorithmic stablecoins. Terra is the largest of them. There was no outside asset to redeem into, only more of a token whose value was falling with every redemption. Fiat reserves and crypto collateral can be short, but they exist independently of the coin. An algorithmic design has nothing outside itself to fall back on.

What does a depeg mean for a balance you play from?

If your casino balance sits in a stablecoin, it is worth whatever that coin trades at, not what the label says. A balance that reads 100 units of a coin trading at 86 cents buys 86 cents' worth per unit on any exchange during the trough, and the fiat exit you might count on is not open to you.

A few habits follow from the three cases above:

  • Know which design your coin uses. Fiat-backed, crypto-collateralized and algorithmic coins fail in different ways, and only some have a route back.
  • Selling into a depeg locks in the discount. With fiat-backed coins the recovery came through redemptions you cannot make yourself, so the decision is whether you trust the reserves, not whether you can redeem.
  • Keep play money and savings in separate places so a wobble in one coin does not decide your session.

For how stablecoins move between wallets and merchants once the peg is steady, see our stablecoin payment gateway notes. We collect every break we cover under Stablecoin Depegs.

Questions players ask

What does depeg mean?

A stablecoin depegs when it trades away from the dollar it is meant to track. USDC, one of the largest fiat-backed coins, bottomed at 86 cents in March 2023 before it came back.

Do stablecoins ever lose value?

Yes. Some lose it for a few days and recover, as USDC did once the banks holding its reserves were backstopped. Others never recover: Terra, the largest algorithmic stablecoin, collapsed in May 2022.

Are stablecoins still risky?

Each design carries its own risk. Fiat-backed coins depend on the banks and assets holding their reserves, crypto-backed coins on liquidations working in a crash, and algorithmic coins on demand for a token the issuer can print. None of them removes risk from a balance.

Where this comes from